MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL
POSITIONAL STRENGTH OVERVIEW BY POSITIONS
10/21/1904
 
CATCHERS
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
New York Giants Roger Bresnahan 1st 4th(tied) 1st
St. Louis Cardinals Mike Grady 2nd 4th(tied) 3rd
Washington Senators Mike Grady 3rd 4th(tied) 4th
Philadelphia Athletics Ossee Schrecongost 4th 4th(tied) 5th
Cleveland Napoleons Harry Bemis 5th 4th(tied) 7th
Boston Beaneaters Pat Moran 6th 4th(tied) 8th
Chicago Cubs Johnny Kling 7th 4th(tied) 9th
Cincinnati Reds Heinie Peitz 8th 4th(tied) 10th
Philadelphia Phillies Red Dooin 9th Fred Jacklitsch 2nd 6th
Detroit Tigers Lew Drill 10th 4th(tied) 11th
St. Louis Browns Joe Sugden 11th 4th(tied) 13th
Boston Americans Lou Criger 12th Tom Doran 1st 2nd
Pittsburgh Pirates Ed Phelps 13th 4th(tied) 14th
Chicago White Sox Ed McFarland 14th Jack Slattery 3rd 12th
New York Highlanders Wilbert Robinson 15th 4th(tied) 15th
Brooklyn Superbas Fred Jacklitsch 16th 4th(tied) 16th
FIRST BASEMEN
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
Chicago Cubs Frank Chance 1st 2nd(tied) 1st
Boston Americans Charlie Hickman 2nd 2nd(tied) 2nd
Philadelphia Athletics Harry Davis 3rd 2nd(tied) 3rd
St. Louis Browns John Anderson 4th 2nd(tied) 5th
Brooklyn Superbas Joe Kelley 5th 2nd(tied) 6th
Detroit Tigers Charlie Hickman 6th 2nd(tied) 7th
Boston Beaneaters Fred Tenney 7th 2nd(tied) 8th
Cleveland Napoleons Charlie Hickman 8th 2nd(tied) 9th
St. Louis Cardinals Jake Beckley 9th 2nd(tied) 10th
New York Giants Dan McGann 10th 2nd(tied) 11th
New York Highlanders John Anderson 11th Jimmy Hart 1st 4th
Cincinnati Reds Joe Kelley 12th 2nd(tied) 12th
Philadelphia Phillies Johnny Lush 13th 2nd(tied) 13th
Washington Senators Scoops Carey 14th 2nd(tied) 14th
Chicago White Sox Jiggs Donahue 15th 2nd(tied) 15th
Pittsburgh Pirates Kitty Bransfield 16th 2nd(tied) 16th
SECOND BASEMEN
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
Philadelphia Athletics Nap Lajoie 1st 4th(tied) 2nd
Cleveland Napoleons Nap Lajoie 2nd Jack Thoney 2nd 1st
Washington Senators Bill Keister 3rd Rabbit Robinson 1st 3rd
Philadelphia Phillies Nap Lajoie 4th 4th(tied) 5th
Chicago White Sox Sam Mertes 5th 4th(tied) 6th
Chicago Cubs Johnny Evers 6th 4th(tied) 7th
New York Highlanders Jimmy Williams 7th 4th(tied) 8th
Pittsburgh Pirates Claude Ritchey 8th 4th(tied) 9th
Boston Beaneaters Gene DeMontreville 9th 4th(tied) 10th
Brooklyn Superbas Tom Daly 10th Tim Flood 3rd 4th
Boston Americans Hobe Ferris 11th 4th(tied) 11th
St. Louis Cardinals John Farrell 12th 4th(tied) 12th
New York Giants Billy Gilbert 13th 4th(tied) 13th
Cincinnati Reds Miller Huggins 14th 4th(tied) 14th
Detroit Tigers Kid Gleason 15th 4th(tied) 15th
St. Louis Browns Dick Padden 16th 4th(tied) 16th
THIRD BASEMEN
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
St. Louis Cardinals John McGraw 1st 3rd(tied) 1st
New York Highlanders John McGraw 2nd 3rd(tied) 2nd
Pittsburgh Pirates Tommy Leach 3rd 3rd(tied) 4th
Cleveland Napoleons Bill Bradley 4th 3rd(tied) 5th
Cincinnati Reds Harry Steinfeldt 5th 3rd(tied) 6th
Chicago White Sox Sammy Strang 6th Pep Clark 1st 3rd
Boston Americans Jimmy Collins 7th 3rd(tied) 7th
Philadelphia Athletics Lave Cross 8th 3rd(tied) 8th
Washington Senators Bill Coughlin 9th 3rd(tied) 9th
New York Giants Art Devlin 10th 3rd(tied) 10th
Boston Beaneaters Jim Delahanty 11th 3rd(tied) 11th
Detroit Tigers Sport McAllister 12th 3rd(tied) 13th
St. Louis Browns Wid Conroy 13th Hunter Hill 2nd 12th
Brooklyn Superbas Sammy Strang 14th 3rd(tied) 14th
Philadelphia Phillies Harry Wolverton 15th 3rd(tied) 15th
Chicago Cubs Doc Casey 16th 3rd(tied) 16th
SHORTSTOPS
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
Pittsburgh Pirates Honus Wagner 1st 2nd(tied) 1st
Boston Americans Freddy Parent 2nd 2nd(tied) 3rd
New York Highlanders Kid Elberfeld 3rd 2nd(tied) 4th
St. Louis Cardinals Bobby Wallace 4th 2nd(tied) 5th
St. Louis Browns Bobby Wallace 5th 2nd(tied) 6th
Detroit Tigers Kid Elberfeld 6th 2nd(tied) 7th
New York Giants Bill Dahlen 7th 2nd(tied) 8th
Chicago Cubs Joe Tinker 8th 2nd(tied) 9th
Boston Beaneaters Herman Long 9th (tied) 2nd(tied) 10th(tied)
Chicago White Sox George Davis 9th (tied) 2nd(tied) 10th(tied)
Brooklyn Superbas Bill Dahlen 11th 2nd(tied) 12th
Washington Senators Billy Clingman 12th Charles Moran 1st 2nd
Philadelphia Athletics Monte Cross 13th 2nd(tied) 13th
Cincinnati Reds Tommy Corcoran 14th 2nd(tied) 14th
Cleveland Napoleons Terry Turner 15th 2nd(tied) 15th
Philadelphia Phillies Rudy Hulswitt 16th 2nd(tied) 16th
LEFT FIELDERS
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
Washington Senators Ed Delahanty 1st 5th(tied) 2nd
Cincinnati Reds Mike Donlin 2nd 5th(tied) 4th
St. Louis Browns Jesse Burkett 3rd 5th(tied) 5th
Philadelphia Phillies Ed Delahanty 4th 5th(tied) 6th
Brooklyn Superbas Jimmy Sheckard 5th 5th(tied) 7th
New York Giants Mike Donlin 6th 5th(tied) 8th
Chicago Cubs Topsy Hartsel 7th Frank Schulte 2nd 3rd
St. Louis Cardinals Jesse Burkett 8th 5th(tied) 9th
Pittsburgh Pirates Fred Clarke 9th 5th(tied) 10th
Philadelphia Athletics Topsy Hartsel 10th Matty McIntyre 1st 1st
Chicago White Sox Ducky Holmes 11th 5th(tied) 11th
New York Highlanders Mike Donlin 12th 5th(tied) 12th
Boston Americans Patsy Dougherty 13th 5th(tied) 15th
Detroit Tigers Billy Lush 14th 5th(tied) 16th
Boston Beaneaters Chick Stahl 15th Frank Murphy 4th 14th
Cleveland Napoleons Harry Bay 16th Rube Vinson 3rd 13th
CENTER FIELDERS
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
Philadelphia Athletics Socks Seybold 1st 5th(tied) 1st
Cincinnati Reds Cy Seymour 2nd 5th(tied) 3rd
Philadelphia Phillies Roy Thomas 3rd 5th(tied) 6th
Washington Senators Jimmy Ryan 4th John O'Neill 3rd 2nd
Chicago Cubs Danny Green 5th 5th(tied) 7th
Chicago White Sox Fielder Jones 6th 5th(tied) 9th
Detroit Tigers Jimmy Barrett 7th 5th(tied) 10th
New York Giants Sam Mertes 8th 5th(tied) 11th
St. Louis Cardinals Emmet Heidrick 9th 5th(tied) 12th
Boston Beaneaters Billy Hamilton 10th 5th(tied) 13th
Pittsburgh Pirates Ginger Beaumont 11th 5th(tied) 14th
Brooklyn Superbas Fielder Jones 12th 5th(tied) 15th
New York Highlanders Joe Kelley 13th Jim Jackson 1st 4th
Boston Americans Chick Stahl 14th Charlie Jones 4th 8th
St. Louis Browns Hugh Duffy 15th Billy Maloney 2nd 5th
Cleveland Napoleons Ollie Pickering 16th 5th(tied) 16th
RIGHT FIELDERS
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
Philadelphia Phillies Elmer Flick 1st 5th(tied) 1st
Cleveland Napoleons Elmer Flick 2nd 5th(tied) 3rd
Detroit Tigers Sam Crawford 3rd 5th(tied) 5th
Cincinnati Reds Sam Crawford 4th 5th(tied) 6th
New York Highlanders Willie Keeler 5th Harry Arndt 1st 2nd
Chicago White Sox Danny Green 6th 5th(tied) 7th
Brooklyn Superbas Harry Lumley 7th 5th(tied) 10th
St. Louis Browns Charlie Hemphill 8th Pinky Swander 3rd 4th
Boston Americans Buck Freeman 9th 5th(tied) 11th
Philadelphia Athletics Elmer Flick 10th 5th(tied) 12th
Pittsburgh Pirates Jimmy Sebring 11th 5th(tied) 13th
New York Giants George Browne 12th 5th(tied) 14th
Boston Beaneaters Buck Freeman 13th Rip Cannell 4th 9th
Washington Senators Sam Dungan 14th 5th(tied) 15th
St. Louis Cardinals Spike Shannon 15th Jack Dunleavy 2nd 8th
Chicago Cubs Jimmy Ryan 16th 5th(tied) 16th
STARTING PITCHERS
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
Pittsburgh Pirates Rube Waddell 1st Mike Lynch 2nd 1st
St. Louis Cardinals Cy Young 2nd Clarence Currie 11th 7th
Boston Americans Cy Young 3rd (tied) George Winter 1st 2nd
Chicago Cubs Jake Weimer 3rd (tied) Frank Corridon 4th(tied) 4th
Philadelphia Phillies Doc White 5th Frank Corridon 7th 8th
Brooklyn Superbas Frank Kitson 6th Oscar Jones 10th 9th
Cleveland Napoleons Earl Moore 7th Gene Wright 3rd 3rd
Cincinnati Reds Noodles Hahn 8th Henry Thielman 12th 10th
New York Highlanders Jack Chesbro 9th Charlie Shields 13th 11th
Philadelphia Athletics Rube Waddell 10th Highball Wilson 4th(tied) 5th
New York Giants Christy Mathewson 11th 15th(tied) 13th
Boston Beaneaters Vic Willis 12th 15th(tied) 15th
St. Louis Browns Fred Glade 13th Charlie Shields 4th(tied) 6th
Detroit Tigers Bill Donovan 14th Frank Owen 8th 12th
Chicago White Sox Frank Smith 15th John Skopec 14th 14th
Washington Senators Tom Hughes 16th Watty Lee 9th 16th
RELIEVERS
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
Cleveland Napoleons Dummy Taylor 1st Gene Wright 3rd 1st
New York Giants Dummy Taylor 2nd 14th(tied) 7th
Philadelphia Phillies Red Donahue 3rd Frank Corridon 6th 3rd
St. Louis Browns Jack Powell 4th Charlie Shields 4th(tied) 2nd
Cincinnati Reds Doc Newton 5th Henry Thielman 10th 4th
St. Louis Cardinals Jack Harper 6th Clarence Currie 9th 5th
Brooklyn Superbas Joe McGinnity 7th Oscar Jones 8th 6th
Boston Beaneaters Ted Lewis 8th 14th(tied) 9th
Washington Senators Al Orth 9th Watty Lee 7th 8th
Chicago White Sox Wiley Piatt 10th John Skopec 12th 12th
Boston Americans Dave Williams 11th Frank Morrissey 1st 10th
Pittsburgh Pirates Sam Leever 12th Mike Lynch 2nd 11th
Philadelphia Athletics Connie McGeehan 13th Connie McGeehan 4th(tied) 13th
Detroit Tigers John Deering 14th John Deering 13th 15th
New York Highlanders Jack Dunn 15th Charlie Shields 11th 14th
Chicago Cubs 16th 14th(tied) 16th
CLOSERS
Team Top player Team ranking Top prospect Organizational ranking Overall ranking
Cleveland Napoleons Dummy Taylor 1st Gene Wright 4th 1st
New York Highlanders Jack Powell 2nd Charlie Shields 12th 8th
Chicago White Sox Wiley Piatt 3rd John Skopec 13th 9th
St. Louis Browns Jack Powell 4th Charlie Shields 5th(tied) 2nd
New York Giants Dummy Taylor 5th 14th(tied) 14th
Philadelphia Phillies Red Donahue 6th Frank Corridon 7th 7th
St. Louis Cardinals Jack Harper 7th Clarence Currie 10th 10th
Cincinnati Reds Doc Newton 8th Henry Thielman 11th 11th
Brooklyn Superbas Joe McGinnity 9th Oscar Jones 9th 12th
Pittsburgh Pirates Sam Leever 10th Mike Lynch 3rd 4th
Boston Americans Norwood Gibson 11th George Winter 1st 3rd
Boston Beaneaters Ted Lewis 12th 14th(tied) 15th
Detroit Tigers Rube Kisinger 13th Frank Owen 5th(tied) 6th
Philadelphia Athletics Bill Duggleby 14th Highball Wilson 2nd 5th
Washington Senators Al Orth 15th Watty Lee 8th 13th
Chicago Cubs 16th 14th(tied) 16th
Tuesday, November 10th , 2026 - OOTP Baseball 26.8 Build 82